Morphosyntax: The Many Ways to Open a Door
A. The Many Ways to Open a Door. The data sets in this section are designed to illustrate processes of sentence formation and the signaling of tense, aspect, and mood. For each language, a basic sentence about a woman opening a door undergoes a series of changes in verb tense, aspect, and mood. There are 13-20 sentences in each language. The sentence numbers are keyed to one another across languages. For example, sentence 3a in Bemba has roughly the same meaning as sentence 3a in Samoan. Students can work through the data sets to identify morphological processes and to make typological comparisons. A set of homework questions is at the end of the Opening Doors data sets. Click on the underlined sentences to hear audio clips.
Russian
How many different ways can Natasha open the door?This set of sentences illustrates the different ways that a single verb stem can be inflected with different morphemes to convey tense, negation, aspect, and mood.
In total, Russian has: 1 non-past tense; 1 past tense;and 2 aspects.These sentences are just a selection of examples.
The first line indicates the standard transliteration from cyrillic to latin for Russian. The second line indicates the grammatical breakdown. The third line provides grammatical glosses and English translations of the morphemes.
1/2 | Natasha otkrivaet dver' | Natasha opens/is opening the door. Present, Imperfective |
|||
1/2 | Natasha | otkrivaj | et | dver' | |
1/2 | Natasha-Nom | open-Impf | 3sg | door-Acc |
3a | Natasha otkrila dver' | Natasha opened the door. Past, Perfective |
||||
3a | Natasha | otkrij | l | a | dver' | |
3a | Natasha-Nom | open-Perf | Past | Fem | door-Acc |
3b | Natasha otkrivala dver' | Natasha opened the door. Past, Imperfective |
||||
3b | Natasha | otkrivaj | l | a | dver' | |
3b | Natasha-Nom | open-Impf | Past | Fem | door-Acc |
4a | Natasha otkroet dver' | Natasha will open the door. Future, Perfective |
|||
4a | Natasha | otkrij | et | dver' | |
4a | Natasha-Nom | open-Perf | 3sg | door-Acc |
4b | Natasha budet otkrivat' dver' | Natasha will open the door. Future, Imperfective |
||||
4b | Natasha | budet | otkrivaj | t' | dver' | |
4b | Natasha-Nom | be-Perf-3sg | open-Impf | Inf | door-Acc |
5a | Natasha ne otkrila dver' | Natasha didn't open the door. Past, Negative, Perfective |
|||||
5a | Natasha | ne | otkrij | l | a | dver' | |
5a | Natasha-Nom | not | open-Perf | Past | Fem | door-Acc |
5b | Natasha ne otkrivala dver' | Natasha didn't open the door. Past, Negative, Imperfective |
|||||
5b | Natasha | ne | otkrivaj | l | a | dver' | |
5b | Natasha-Nom | not | open-Impf | Past | Fem | door-Acc |
6a | Natasha ne otkroet dver' | Natasha won't open the door. Future, Negative, Perfective |
||||
6a | Natasha | ne | otkrij | et | dver' | |
6a | Natasha-Nom | not | open-Perf | 3sg | door-Acc |
6b | Natasha ne budet otkrivat' dver' | Natasha won't open the door. Future, Negative, Imperfective |
|||||
6b | Natasha | ne | budet | otkrivaj | t' | dver' | |
6b | Natasha-Nom | not | be-Perf-3sg | open-Impf | Inf | door-Acc |
7 | Natasha dolzhna otkrit' dver' | Natasha should open the door. Subjunctive, Perfective |
||||
7 | Natasha | dolzhna | otkrij | t' | dver' | |
7 | Natasha-Nom | should-Fem | open-Perf | Inf | door-Acc |
8a | Otkroite dver' | Open the door! Imperative, Perfective |
||
8a | otkrij | jte | dver' | |
8a | open-Perf | Imp | door-Acc |
8b | Otkrivajte dver' | Open the door! Imperative, Imperfective |
||
8b | otkrivaj | jte | dver' | |
8b | open-Impf | Imp | door-Acc |
9 | Natasha otkrila dver' ? | Did Natasha open the door? Question, Perfective |
||||
9 | Natasha | otkrij | l | a | dver' | |
9 | Natasha-Nom | open-Perf | Past | Fem | door-Acc |
10 | Natasha vsegda otkrivaet dver'. | Natasha always opens the door. Present, Imperfective |
||||
10 | Natasha | vsegda | otkrivaj | et | dver' | |
10 | Natasha-Nom | always | open-Impf | 3sg | door-Acc |
11 | Natasha otkrila dver' snova i snova. | Natasha opened the door over and over again. Past, Perfective |
|||||||
11 | Natasha | otkrij | l | a | dver' | snova | i | snova | |
11 | Natasha-Nom | open-Perf | Past | Fem | door-Acc | over | and | over |
Bemba
How many different ways can Mulenga open the door?
This set of sentences illustrates the different ways that a single verb stem can be inflected with different morphemes to convey tense, negation, aspect, and mood.
In total, Bemba has: 1 present tense; 3 basic past tenses (past today, past recent, and past remote); 2 past perfect tenses (today and remote); 3 future tenses (inceptive, today future, and later future); 2 progressive aspect markers; 1 habitual aspect marker; and 5 other mood markers for imperatives, hypotheticals, and conditionals. These sentences are just a selection of examples.
The first line indicates the correct spelling in Zambia's standard orthography for Bemba. The second line indicates the grammatical breakdown. The third line provides grammatical glosses and English translations of the morphemes.
1 | Mulenga aaisula icibi | Mulenga opens the door. Present |
||||
1 | Mulenga | a | aa | isula | icibi | |
1 | 3sg | Pres | open | door |
2 | Mulenga aleeisula icibi | Mulenga is opening the door. Present Progressive |
||||
2 | Mulenga | a | lee | isula | icibi | |
2 | 3sg | Prog | open | door |
3a | Mulenga aacisula icibi | Mulenga opened the door. Past Today |
||||
3a | Mulenga | a | aaci | isula | icibi | |
3a | 3sg | TPst | open | door |
3b | Mulenga aaliisula icibi | Mulenga opened the door. Past Recent (not today) |
||||
3b | Mulenga | a | alii | isula | icibi | |
3b | 3sg | Rpst | open | door |
3c | Mulenga aaliswile icibi | Mulenga opened the door. Past Remote |
|||||
3c | Mulenga | a | aali | isul | -ile | icibi | |
3c | 3sg | RmPst | open | RmPst | door |
3d | Mulenga aaliisula icibi | Mulenga opened the door. Past Perfect, Remote Resultative = action occurred long ago and with permanent effect. |
||||
3d | Mulenga | a | aali | isula | icibi | |
3d | 3sg | RmPstP | open | door |
4a | Mulenga alaaisula icibi | Mulenga will open the door. Future Today Inceptive (is about to open...) |
||||
4a | Mulenga | a | alaa | isula | icibi | |
4a | 3sg | Inc | open | door |
4c | Mulenga akeesula icibi | Mulenga will open the door. Future, Not Today |
||||
4c | Mulenga | a | ka | isula | icibi | |
4c | 3sg | Fut | open | door |
5a | Mulenga taacisula icibi | Mulenga didn't open the door. Negative, Today Past |
|||||
5a | Mulenga | ta | a | aaci | isula | icibi | |
5a | Neg | 3sg | Tpst | open | door |
5b | Mulenga taiswile icibi | Mulenga didn't open the door. Negative, Recent Past |
||||||
5b | Mulenga | ta | a | aa | isul | ile | icibi | |
5b | Neg | 3sg | Rpst | open | RPst | door |
6a | Mulenga taisule icibi | Mulenga will not open the door. Negative, Future Today |
||||||
6a | Mulenga | ta | a | aa | isul | e | icibi | |
6a | Neg | 3sg | TFut | open | Neg | door |
6b | Mulenga takeesule icibi | Mulenga will not open the door. Negative, Future Tomorrow or Later |
||||||
6b | Mulenga | ta | a | aaka | isul | e | icibi | |
6b | Neg | 3sg | NegFut | open | Neg | door |
7 | Mulenga esule icibi | Mulenga should open the door. Subjunctive |
||||
7 | Mulenga | a | isul | e | icibi | |
7 | 3sg | open | Subj | door |
8a | Isula icibi | Open the door! Imperative (one person or a child) |
||
8a | 0 | isula | icibi | |
8a | 2sg | open | door |
8b | Isuleeni icibi | Open the door! Imperative (to a group) |
||
8b | isul | eeni | icibi | |
8b | open | 2pl | door |
9a | Bushe Mulenga aacisula icibi ? | Did Mulenga open the door? Question |
|||||
9a | Bushe | Mulenga | a | aaci | isula | icibi | |
9a | Q | 3sg | TPst | open | door |
9b | Mulenga aacisula icibi ? | Did Mulenga open the door? Question |
||||
9b | Mulenga | a | aaci | isula | icibi | |
9b | 3sg | TPst | open | door |
10 | Mulenga alaisula icibi | Mulenga always opens the door. Habitual |
||||
10 | Mulenga | a | la | isula | icibi | |
10 | 3sg | la | open | door |
11a | Mulenga alaisulesula icibi | Mulenga opened the door over and over again. Repetitive |
|||||
11a | Mulenga | a | la | isula | isula | icibi | |
11a | 3sg | la | open | open | door |
12 | Mulenga naaisula icibi | Mulenga has opened the door. Past Perfect Today |
||||
12 | Mulenga | naa | a | isula | icibi | |
12 | TPstP | 3sg | open | door |
Samoan
How many different ways can Sina open the door?
This set of sentences illustrates the different ways that a single verb stem can be inflected with different morphemes to convey tense, negation, aspect, and mood.
Samoan, like most Polynesian languages, is a verb-initial language where the verb complex normally comes first in the sentence before either the subject or the object. This verb complex consists of the verb root which is preceded by a particle that marks tense and aspect. The verb root itself does not change except with a few important exceptions to mark number. Tense and aspect are signaled by the 11 different tense-aspect markers that precede the verb root in the verb complex. The Samoan language has: a present indefinite tense; a present progressive; a present immediate/completive; two past tenses (simple past, past perfect); a future tense; and aspect markers including a prescriptive (marking that an action should take place) and a desiderative (marking the desirability of an action). The following sentences are just a selection of examples and do not demonstrate the full extent of Samoan's tense-aspect system.
The first line indicates the Samoan transcription of the sentence. The second line indicates the grammatical breakdown. The third line provides grammatical glosses and English translations of the morphemes.
1 | E tatala e Sina le faitoto'a | Sina opens the door. Present |
|||||
1 | E | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
1 | Pres | open | Erg | art | door |
2 | 'Olo'o tatala e Sina le faitoto'a | Sina is opening the door. Present progressive |
|||||
2 | 'Olo'o | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
2 | Prog | open | Erg | art | door |
3a | Na tatala e Sina le faitoto'a | Sina opened the door. Simple Past |
|||||
3a | Na | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
3a | Past | open | Erg | art | door |
3b | Sa: tatala e Sina le faitoto'a | Sina opened the door. Past Perfect |
|||||
3b | Sa: | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
3b | PstP | open | Erg | art | door |
4 | 'Ole'a: tatala e Sina le faitoto'a | Sina will open the door. Future |
|||||
4 | 'Ole'a: | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
4 | Fut | open | Erg | art | door |
5 | E le'i tatala e Sina le faitoto'a ananafi. | Sina didn't open the door yesterday. Neg Past |
|||||||
5 | E | le'i | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | ananafi | |
5 | Pres | Neg-Past | open | Erg | art | door | yesterday |
6a | E le tatala e Sina le faitoto'a. | Sina will not open the door. Neg Present/Future |
||||||
6a | E | le | tatala | e | Sina | le | ||
6a | Pres | Neg-ImpFut | open | Erg | art | door |
6b | E le'o tatala e Sina le faitoto'a. | Sina isn't opening the door. Neg Pres Prog |
||||||
6b | E | le'o | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
6b | Pres | Neg-Prog | open | Erg | art | door |
7 | E tatau ona tatala e Sina le faitoto'a. | Sina should open the door. Subjunctive |
|||||||
7 | E | tatau | ona | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
7 | Pres | should | aux | open | Erg | art | door |
8 | Tatala le faitoto'a. | Open the door. Imperative |
||
8 | tatala | le | faitoto'a | |
8 | open | art | door |
9 | Sa: tatala e Sina le faitoto'a ? | Did Sina open the door? Question |
|||||
9 | Sa: | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
9 | PstP | open | Erg | art | door |
10 | E ma:sani ona tatala e Sina le faitoto'a. | Sina always opens the door. Habitual |
|||||||
10 | E | ma:sani | ona | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
10 | Pres | always | aux | open | Erg | art | door |
11 | Sa: tatala ma toe tatala e Sina le faitoto'a. | Sina opened the door over and over again. Subjunctive |
||||||||
11 | Sa: | tatala | toe | ma | tatala | e | Sina | le | faitoto'a | |
11 | PstP | open | and | again | open | Erg | art | door |
Homework
Opening DoorsStudy the data sets for Bemba, Russian, and Samoan and write up a 850-1000 word (typed, single-spaced) discussion of the following questions:
- What are some of the key differences in the ways that Bemba, Russian, and Samoan handle verb tense (past, present, future)?
- Which language seems to have the greatest number of options in tense, aspect, and mood marking? Explain.
- Do you see any places where tense/aspect/mood nuances in the language seem to get lost in the translation into English?
- How is the syntax of questions different from the syntax of statements in these languages?
- Do you see anything interesting going on in sentence 11?
- Other remarks?